Aug 21, 2026 · 27 min
Why heartbreak became summer’s defining pop sound
The pop girlies are sad
The episode connects a country chart breakthrough and a wave of melancholy pop to the cultural meanings audiences attach to music.
- 1Ella Langley’s “Choosin’ Texas” became 2026’s clearest song-of-the-summer contender through heartbreak, chart power, and Nashville significance.
- 2Audiences project competing political narratives onto Langley even as she has kept her personal views largely out of the music’s center.
- 3Sad songs endure in summer because warmth and freedom can sharpen exclusion, longing, envy, and nostalgia.
Don't miss
Alex Frank argues that summer can intensify exclusion, longing, envy, and nostalgia, explaining why some of the season’s most enduring songs are sad.
The brief
Ella Langley’s “Choosin’ Texas” has become the leading song-of-the-summer contender, combining a relaxed country sound with a story of romantic loss and extraordinary chart success.
Rolling Stone writer Marissa Moss places Langley’s rise in Nashville’s changing landscape, while noting how conservatives and liberals project political meanings onto an artist who has largely avoided them.
Vogue contributor Alex Frank broadens the frame to a sad-girl summer, from Olivia Rodrigo’s uncertainty to Phoebe Bridgers’ private and collective despair.
Charli XCX’s more serious direction raises a larger question: whether pop’s turn toward melancholy reflects a broader cultural mood rather than a passing trend.
The episode’s sharpest idea is that summer intensifies sadness, making exclusion, longing, envy, and nostalgia more vivid—and helping melancholy songs last.
Langley’s hit ultimately wins the zeitgeist, even as songs by Olivia Rodrigo and others may better capture listeners’ private emotional lives.
Featuring
Ella Langley
Phoebe Bridgers
Taylor SwiftListen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.