Oct 4, 2026 · 52 min

Snyder warns America is weakening its own power

Pivot Extra: Timothy Snyder on America’s Superpower Suicide

The conversation connects reduced support for Ukraine to the credibility of American alliances, deterrence, democracy, and national power.

3 key takeaways

1Snyder argues that abandoning Ukraine would damage American diplomatic credibility and weaken the broader system of deterrence.
2The discussion links strained US-Canada relations and short-term policymaking to a wider retreat from alliances and national investment.
3Despite severe hardship, Ukraine’s resilience, Russia’s lack of progress, and possible shifts in Western policy offer cautious reasons for optimism.

Don't miss

Snyder introduces “superpower suicide” to describe how damage to alliances, education, scientific research, and democratic institutions can weaken the foundations of American power.

The brief

Historian Timothy Snyder joins Scott Galloway from Toronto after visiting Kharkiv, describing a society living through prolonged war while sustaining public resolve and daily life under pressure.

Snyder argues that sharply reduced American support has altered the war’s trajectory, while Europe’s response and Ukraine’s asymmetric strengths complicate Russia’s strategy of waiting out Western attention.

The stakes extend beyond the battlefield: Ukraine’s surrendered nuclear weapons and broken security assurances raise questions about deterrence, diplomacy, and whether future partners can trust American commitments.

The conversation widens to strained US-Canada relations, Mark Carney’s international standing, and a policy style Snyder sees as driven by short-term interests rather than durable national power.

Snyder’s phrase “superpower suicide” captures his broader concern that weakened alliances, education, science, and democratic institutions could erode the foundations of American influence.

He closes with cautious optimism: Russia has not achieved its aims, winter may create pressure, and changing Western policy could give Ukraine leverage toward an end to the war.

Featuring

Tim Snyder