Oct 5, 2026 · 23 min
Maine tests Collins’s hold on a pivotal Senate seat
The path to Senate control runs through this state
The race pits Susan Collins’s moderate brand and Senate influence against a late Democratic challenger in a contest that could still shape control of the chamber.
- 1Troy Jackson entered after Graham Plattner’s withdrawal, leaving him little time to inherit an existing progressive campaign movement.
- 2Susan Collins is balancing her record delivering federal funds with efforts to present herself as a check on President Trump.
- 3Early voting, Republican advertising, outside money, and four debates will determine whether Maine remains a serious Senate pickup opportunity.
Don't miss
The discussion weighs whether Collins can credibly present herself as a check on President Trump while defending her Senate record and seniority.
The brief
Maine’s Senate race remains competitive because Susan Collins’s long-standing popularity collides with the state’s recent support for Democratic presidential candidates and Democrats’ hopes of a pickup.
Troy Jackson entered after Graham Plattner withdrew amid allegations he denied, giving the labor-backed Maine politician limited time to build recognition and transfer the campaign’s progressive energy.
Collins is campaigning on her appropriations power and as a check on President Trump, but federal funding rescissions and her voting record complicate both arguments.
Steve Mistler describes a race where Republican advertising, attacks on Jackson, dark money, and limited transparency could matter as early voting begins.
The contest may no longer top the national Senate map, yet its cost, competitiveness, and four upcoming debates keep Maine consequential for both campaigns.
Miles Parks
Tamara Keith
Susan Collins
Troy JacksonListen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.