Sep 20, 2026 · 1h 6m
Jessica Tarlov argues Democrats must fight beyond friendly media
Fighting with Fox News feat. Jessica Tarlov
The conversation tests whether Democrats can persuade skeptical voters by confronting difficult issues and political opponents where those voters already are.
- 1Jessica Tarlov says persuasion starts with trust and opening minds, not expecting voters to change identities overnight.
- 2The Fox News debate pits audience reach and direct persuasion against the risks of viral clips and hostile media incentives.
- 3Democrats need to address immigration, crime, the economy, and corruption directly while drawing sharper contrasts with Trump’s policies.
Don't miss
Tarlov makes the case that corruption can unite voters by connecting crypto schemes, government contracts, and personal enrichment.
The brief
Jessica Tarlov joins Tommy Vietor to discuss her role as the lone liberal voice on The Five, where four-on-one clashes coexist with unexpectedly collegial relationships.
Tarlov argues that political persuasion is incremental: Democrats should build trust, show up consistently, and understand voters who do not make politics their identity.
The central strategic fight is whether Democratic candidates should appear on Fox News, trading a large, mixed audience against hostile formats and clip-driven incentives.
The discussion turns to messaging on immigration, crime, policing, healthcare, the economy, and artificial intelligence, with Tarlov urging Democrats to acknowledge concerns directly.
The sharpest closing argument centers on corruption, including crypto schemes, government contracts, and personal enrichment as issues that could unite voters against Trump’s political machine.
Featuring
Jessica Tarlov
Donald John Trump
Mark Carney
I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing FriendsBooks & mentions
Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.