Aug 20, 2026 · 43 min
Investors should judge income by risk, not yield
Not all income is created equal with Helen Mason | Schroders
The episode challenges Australia’s dividend-first investing culture and explains how public credit can offer more transparent, contractual income.
- 1Dividends are discretionary, while credit income depends on contractual claims and an investment’s position in the capital structure.
- 2Private credit can conceal illiquidity, inconsistent underwriting and weak recovery prospects behind an attractive headline yield.
- 3Credit analysts focus on debt coverage, liquidity and legal protections, offering signals that may precede movements in equity markets.
Don't miss
Helen Mason explains why “high yielding” refers to access to subordinated public credit, including bank Tier 2 securities, rather than simply distressed debt.
The brief
Helen Mason of Schroders questions Australia’s preference for dividends and franking credits, arguing that income should be judged by reliability, contractual status, liquidity and risk.
Using three pig figures and building blocks, Mason contrasts discretionary equity dividends with private and public credit, warning that yield-seeking can obscure weak protections.
Her sharpest criticism is reserved for private credit: opaque portfolios, uneven deal quality and illiquidity can leave investors unable to assess how much protection a loan really offers.
Public credit, she argues, gives retail investors clearer pricing and liquidity, while Australia’s expanding issuance market is broadening the opportunity set beyond equities.
The practical test is simple but demanding: examine debt coverage, cash flow, capital structure, liquidity and legal protections before deciding whether yield adequately compensates for risk.
What was said on this episode
38 statements · 17 positive · 16 negative · 5 neutral
Yield alone is not an investment strategy.
“Yield is a symptom, it's not a strategy.”
Listen at 0:00
Bond-market developments generally precede equity-market developments.
“Things tend to happen in the bond market before you see it in the equity markets.”
Listen at 0:02
Equities were historically competitive for income before the current regime.
“equity for income did stack up.”
Listen at 3:16
The ASX 200 offers roughly 3.2% dividend yield, or 4.2% after franking.
“the ASX 200 is, you know, what, giving you a 12-month dividend yield of roughly 3.2, you frank that, that is 4.2%.”
Listen at 3:44
Australian public credit yields 5.36% and ranks above equities in the capital stack.
“the Australian public credit index is 5.36 today. And that's an A-rated high quality index. And if we refer back to my capital stack, it's higher in the capital stack than equities.”
Listen at 4:02
Equity income is discretionary rather than contractually guaranteed.
“the income that you're actually getting on equities is discretionary.”
Listen at 5:38
Company management can change or eliminate dividends without shareholder consent.
“management can change their minds at any point in time and they don't have to consult you as a shareholder.”
Listen at 5:43
Low base rates drove private-credit growth through investor yield-seeking.
“The private credit asset class really thrived in an environment of low base rates because there was that reach for yield.”
Listen at 6:52
Private-credit valuations are currently below expected levels.
“valuations are kind of not what they were supposed to be.”
Listen at 7:25
Private-credit underwriting may have loosened from 65% to 85% LVRs.
“loans may have been written at 65% LVRs and now written at 85% LVRs just in order to get the deals done.”
Listen at 7:32
Public-credit coupons are contractual legal obligations rather than discretionary payments.
“my coupons are not discretionary. They're a legal obligation. They have to be paid to me.”
Listen at 8:29
The public-credit index currently yields over 5.5%.
“the index is, you know, over 5.5% at the moment.”
Listen at 8:55
Private-credit deal quality has declined as competition and supply increased.
“the quality of those deals has declined.”
Listen at 10:57
Retail investors cannot readily assess private-credit fund exposures.
“as a retail investor in these funds, they're opaque. So you have no idea what exposure you have. to good deals or bad deals.”
Listen at 12:42
Opaque private-credit risks make appropriate risk pricing difficult.
“if you can't see under the bonnet and you can't assess the risk that you're taking, how can you possibly expect a price for that risk?”
Listen at 13:00
Australian public credit primarily involves large, high-quality institutions.
“public credit in Australia, you're talking the big, big banks. you know, the Westpacks, the CBAs, you're talking the Woolworths and the Coles or the major airports or the seaports”
Listen at 13:30
Private loans may take months to sell because they are not actively traded.
“if an organisation wanted to get out of that loan, they would have to canvass some buyers who potentially would then want to step in and buy and that can take many months.”
Listen at 14:26
Some failed private-credit deals convert worthless debt into equity.
“the debt is worthless so it gets converted to equity”
Listen at 15:12
Fixed-income ETF growth has expanded Schroders’ fund-management opportunity.
“the growth of the ETF market for fixed income products has been great for our growth as fund managers”
Listen at 17:13
Australian financial issuance is close to surpassing last year’s total.
“we are like maybe 10 billion off beating last year's number in financials”
Listen at 18:20
Australian credit structurally offers higher risk premiums than offshore markets.
“we do tend to have structurally higher risk premium in Australia.”
Listen at 19:46
Australian credit deals now reach billions and are heavily oversubscribed.
“now we're doing deals of $2 billion, $3 billion, $4 billion, and they're getting that away. And books are six to eight times oversubscribed”
Listen at 20:44
Income investors should distinguish discretionary from contractual yield.
“I want to know, is that yield discretionary? Is it contractual? Can it be switched off without my consent?”
Listen at 21:56
Investors should assess risk and capital-stack position before accepting yield.
“I want to know what risk am I taking to access that yield? Where am I in the capital stack?”
Listen at 22:04
Highly regulated companies provide more predictable multi-year cash flows for debt investors.
“we love companies that are highly regulated, for example, because we get to see their cash flows out to, you know, five, six, seven years.”
Listen at 25:43
Credit analysis prioritizes cash flow available for debt service.
“We're about cash flow. Show us the money.”
Listen at 27:18
Debt holders have limited upside and primarily face repayment or loss outcomes.
“the risk is asymmetric. So we either get our money back or we don't. And so there's no upside for us.”
Listen at 28:51
Pricing risk for a 100-year bond is extremely difficult.
“I think pricing 100-year risk is really hard to do.”
Listen at 29:28
Credit models assess whether debt coverage is adequate.
“we're modelling to make sure that the debt coverage is appropriate.”
Listen at 30:57
Global credit markets are currently expensive.
“global credit markets are really expensive at the moment.”
Listen at 32:45
Australian credit risk premiums exceed those in major offshore markets.
“we are structurally higher than what you're achieving in the US and in Europe and in other offshore markets.”
Listen at 33:01
Australian banks are currently well provisioned for potential downturns.
“the banks are pretty well provisioned”
Listen at 33:31
Australian banks will experience some increase in loan losses.
“there will be some increase in loan losses that they're going to see.”
Listen at 34:03
A property-price decline of around 15% would be plausible.
“even 15 wouldn't be unreasonable”
Listen at 34:13
A property downturn would likely be less catastrophic than media portrayals suggest.
“it's not as catastrophic as... as it kind of gets played out in the press.”
Listen at 34:56
Australian Tier 1 bank hybrids are disappearing from the retail market.
“hybrids in Australia so tier one bank hybrids are disappearing”
Listen at 35:55
Diversification is especially important in risky markets.
“diversification is really key.”
Listen at 40:26
Public credit should generally have lower return volatility than equities.
“And lower volatility, yeah, which you should expect.”
Listen at 41:11
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Featuring
Schroders
Commonwealth Bank
Peppa PigListen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.