Aug 28, 2026 · 36 min
Clancy trial tests how courts understand postpartum psychosis
Lindsay Clancy Is on Trial. So Is Postpartum Psychosis.
The case forces a painful question about criminal responsibility, psychiatric treatment, and whether fear of prosecution could deter women from seeking help.
- 1Prosecutors portray Lindsay Clancy as an intentional planner, while the defense argues postpartum psychosis drove the killings.
- 2Testimony from relatives and medical providers presents a complicated picture of a devoted mother who was also seeking psychiatric help.
- 3The verdict could shape public understanding of postpartum crises and influence whether people disclose frightening symptoms before they escalate.
Don't miss
Experts testify that Lindsay Clancy heard a commanding voice telling her to kill her children, crystallizing the trial’s central dispute over postpartum psychosis.
The brief
Lindsay Clancy is on trial for killing her three children and has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. The case turns on whether she acted intentionally or during postpartum psychosis.
The prosecution describes Clancy as a perfectionist who planned the killings, while testimony from family and medical providers depicts a devoted mother who was seeking help.
The defense says inadequate treatment allowed postpartum psychosis to worsen; experts testified that Clancy heard a commanding voice telling her to kill her children.
Outside the courthouse, supporters shared experiences of postpartum anxiety, depression, paranoia, and intrusive thoughts, while critics insisted attention remain on the murdered children.
Ellen Barry and Natalie Kitroeff examine how the verdict could affect treatment, disclosure, and fears that postpartum psychiatric symptoms will be criminalized.
The episode closes with updates on President Trump’s proposed Lake Ontario renaming and deadly floods in Nepal and Tibet.
Featuring
Donald John Trump
The New York TimesBooks & mentions
Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.